GalionToon

Techniques

Seven mistakes that give away an amateur pixel art sprite

By · September 25, 2026

A pixel art sprite is judged in a second. Even if the character design is good, there are technical details that instantly show that whoever made it is just starting out. The good news is that almost all of them are easy to fix once you know how to spot them. Here are the seven most common ones, each with the same character before and after.

Examples to compare the mistake with the fix.

1. An uncontrolled palette

The same sprite with more than 1500 different shades next to the version with 19 colours
Left: more than 1500 different shades. Right: the same features with 19 colours.

When every pixel has a slightly different shade, the sprite loses strength: it looks like a shrunken photo, not a drawing. In pixel art, every colour is a decision. A short palette, of 16 to 32 colours, forces you to choose and makes shapes read clearly. When you start a sprite, fix the palette before you draw.

2. Blurred edges

Sprite with edges blurred by interpolated scaling next to the same sprite with sharp edges
Left: interpolated scaling, blurred edges. Right: every pixel in its place.

It is the most frequent mistake, and it is almost never intentional. It appears when you use an anti-aliased brush or resize the image with smooth resampling, which invents in-between pixels. Draw with a 1-pixel brush without smoothing and, when enlarging, always use “nearest neighbour” resampling and whole multiples: 2×, 3×, 4×.

3. Pillow shading

Sprite dark along the whole outline and light in the centre next to the same sprite with shadows that follow its shape
Left: dark all around the edge and light in the centre. Right: shadows that follow the shape and the light.

It gets its name because the result looks like a cushion: everything darkens towards the outline and lightens in the centre, regardless of where the light comes from. The volume ends up flat and soft. Before shading, decide where the light source is and think about the shape of each part: the shadow falls on the side opposite the light, not all around.

16 by 16 pixel potion: on the left with pillow shading, a dark ring and a light centre; on the right lit from the top left, with a highlight and shadow at the bottom right
16 × 16 pixel potion: the same mistake on an object, with barely 9 colours.

On a small object the effect is even clearer. The potion on the left looks like a target; the one on the right, like a glass sphere: the light comes in from the top left, leaves a highlight and the shadow gathers at the bottom right. Same size, almost the same colours.

4. A uniform black outline

Sprite with a thick black outline around everything that swallows the antlers next to the same sprite with outlines in the colour of each area
Left: a black outline around everything; the antlers disappear. Right: outlines that respect each area.

A 1-pixel black outline around the whole sprite feels safe, but it eats up fine details, such as the antlers, and makes everything weigh the same. Try selective outlining: use a darker version of each area’s colour and keep black for the spots where you really need to separate shapes.

Grass tile of 16 by 16 repeated nine times: on the left each tile has a dark border and a grid shows; on the right the grass continues without breaks
A grass tile repeated 3 × 3: with a border you see the grid; without one, the ground is continuous.

Backgrounds suffer from the same thing, only multiplied. A scenery tile is repeated dozens of times: if it has an outline, the ground turns into a grid. Tiles are not outlined; they are drawn so that their right edge continues into the left one and the top edge into the bottom one.

5. Inconsistent lighting

Sprite with the light coming from the left at the top and from the right at the bottom next to the same sprite with a single light source
Left: at the top the light comes from the left and at the bottom, from the right (exaggerated so it shows). Right: a single light for the whole character.

When each part is shaded separately, it is easy for the head to be lit from one side and the legs from the other. The eye cannot explain it, but it notices that something is off. Choose one light source for the whole sprite and check it as a whole when you finish, not part by part.

6. Features that get lost

Sprite with the head and antlers reduced to realistic proportions next to the same sprite with exaggerated features
Left: head and antlers in “realistic” proportion; the glasses and the face get lost. Right: exaggerated features that read.

It is not a mistake in itself: realistic proportions are a style choice. But at sprite size, with few pixels, whatever is not exaggerated disappears. If the face, the glasses or the antlers define the character, give them more room than they would have in reality. A big head and strong features are recognised from afar.

7. Animating everything as a block

Two-frame animation: on the left the whole sprite moves up and down as a block; on the right the body sinks and the feet stay on the ground
Left: everything rises and falls at once and the feet float. Right: the body breathes and the feet stay on the ground.

The simplest idle animation is moving the character one pixel up and down. If everything moves at once, it looks like a cardboard cut-out and the feet leave the ground. Just keep the feet still and sink the rest of the body by one pixel, and the same pair of frames seems to breathe. Always move by whole pixels: rotating or scaling a small sprite blurs it.

Bonus: a spinning coin

Coin spinning in six frames: on the left each frame is the coin squeezed with interpolation and the edges blur; on the right each frame is drawn pixel by pixel with 4 colours
Left: the same coin squeezed with interpolation, 66 colours. Right: six drawn frames, 4 colours.

A spinning object is the ultimate test of mistakes 2 and 7 together. If each frame is generated by squeezing the coin with smooth scaling, blurry edges and colours nobody chose appear. By drawing each frame, with its outline and highlight, the coin stays sharp with only 4 colours. They are six small drawings, and the difference shows at any size.

How to train your eye

  • Look at the sprite at real size, without zooming in. Whatever does not read at 1× needs simplifying.
  • Fill the silhouette with a single colour: if the pose is not recognisable, the problem is the shape, not the detail.
  • Flip the sprite horizontally from time to time. Proportion and lighting mistakes jump out.
  • Count the colours. In Pixel Galion, the Indexing menu works with a fixed palette, and “Index automatically (generate palette)” creates one from your drawing.
  • Practise with small objects before characters: a potion, a coin or a 16 × 16 pixel tile fit into an afternoon and teach light, outline and animation without distractions.

If you want to practise, the guide How to make a pixel art animation starts from scratch, and How to create a sprite sheet for a video game explains how to take the result into a game. And if you need to enlarge a sprite to publish it, How to resize an image for social media explains why “nearest neighbour” resampling is the only one that respects the pixels.

Open GalionToon

More articles